Subaru Legacy (2005-2009)

SUBARU LEGACY GT SPEC B CARSTOCKSPECIALTY
$4.9K ▼ $5.9K (−54.9%)12 mo
UNDERVALUEDUndervalued vs trend — but volatile.
Supported (limited) · 18 sold + 422 active
Fair value$4.9K ($4.3K–$5.5K)
Typical ask$4.2K
Recent sold$7.6K
Current valueModerate
12-mo trendRoughly flat · 5-in-10 up · 39% calls right
Buyer: Prices look low vs trend — a reasonable entry; confirm condition and title.
Seller: Buyers here are value-focused; price near sold comps ($8k) for a timely sale.
Watcher: Volatile — wait for a clearer trend.
💰 Pricing your car to sell
Quick sale$4.0Ksells fast
Fair$7.6Krecent comps
List$8.2Kroom to negotiate
Stretch$8.9Kexceptional
🎯 Buying guide
Strong deal below $4.3K · Fair $4.3K–$5.5K · careful above $5.6K

Due to a thin data state, this market outlook for the Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) is low-confidence. The market shows a high undervaluation score of 72.4, with appreciation momentum at 37.41 and depreciation risk at 55.24.

What It's Actually Worth

Blended value of a standard 18 yr, 120k mi example, ~$4.9K now. The green line weighs confirmed auction sales most heavily (the amber dots — what cars actually hammered for), blends in fast-selling "just-missed" listings, and lightly smooths out month-to-month composition noise.

2021-09 2026-11 $21.0K $4.0K
━ blended true value ● confirmed auction sales (dot size = volume)
◫ 72 confirmed sales (72 auction)·91 sales tracked·63 months tracked·since 2021-09·2761 active listings

Did our model work? 39% direction calls right

Each faint amber line is a forecast we would have made at that point in the past (12-mo horizon), drawn against what actually happened (blue). Over 18 scored forecasts: 39% got the direction right, median value error ±150%.

2017-11 2026-11 $103K $1.2K
━ actual ╱ past predictions (ghosts)

Walk-forward: each ghost uses only data available at that date — no hindsight. Data-backed market intelligence, not a guaranteed prediction. Figures are modeled estimates from asking prices, sold comps, and public economic indicators; they can be wrong. Not financial advice.

Auction Scorecard gavel in range 6 in 10

We replayed 44 past auctions in this market — predicting each hammer price from market data before the sale (no hindsight). Typical miss: ±28%; the gavel landed inside our predicted range 6 in 10 of the time, and we lean slightly low on average.

SoldCarOur rangeHammer
2026-10-28 2009 · 69k mi $3.7K–$8.2K $5.6K ✓
2026-09-18 2007 · 109k mi $3.2K–$7.1K $7.3K ✗
2026-07-22 2009 · 116k mi $3.9K–$8.7K $8.0K ✓
2026-06-17 2005 · 135k mi $4.6K–$10.2K $3.6K ✗
2026-04-29 2005 · 94k mi $5.2K–$11.5K $5.4K ✓
2026-02-10 2005 · 57k mi $8.0K–$17.6K $10.1K ✓
2026-02-08 2005 · 165k mi $6.3K–$13.9K $6.3K ✓
2026-01-23 2005 · 7k mi $8.4K–$18.6K $7.1K ✗

No-lookahead: predictions are made before each auction closes; the scorecard grades confirmed sold auctions only (no-sales excluded). A modeled estimate, not a guarantee. Data-backed market intelligence, not a guaranteed prediction. Figures are modeled estimates from asking prices, sold comps, and public economic indicators; they can be wrong. Not financial advice.

Where We Think It's Headed

Probability and range, not a single number. Wider = less certain (not bigger gains).

2021-09 now +24mo $43.1K $854
HorizonDirectionProbabilityConfidencePast accuracy
6 mo UP 51% Low 63%
12 mo UP 53% Low 39%
24 mo UP 54% Low 17%

Data-backed market intelligence, not a guaranteed prediction. Figures are modeled estimates from asking prices, sold comps, and public economic indicators; they can be wrong. Not financial advice.

If You’d Bought in 2021

$100K invested 2021-09 → today (5.2 yrs), this car vs where else you could've put the money. Rebased to 100 at the start; the dashed line is inflation (break-even).

$66.9K$194K$228K$75.7K$124K 2021 2026 298 100
━ This car $66.9K━ S&P 500 $194K━ Gold $228K━ Luxury $75.7K━ Housing $124K₿ Bitcoin $169K (off-scale)
Lost ground to inflation. The Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) roughly 0.7×'d your money (a real 46% LOSS to inflation). It LAGGED the stock market by about 66% — the same money in the S&P 500 would be larger. It trailed housing (-46%). (Price only — a real round-trip also loses ~10–20% to buy/sell fees and carrying costs.)
📷 Share this comparison →

Why We Think This

Appreciation Momentum
22
Undervaluation
78
Liquidity
44
Speculation Opportunity
52
Depreciation Risk
64
Overvaluation
31
-37% vs 2-yr avg pct vs trailing 24mo
-38% vs 3-yr trend pct vs trailing 36mo
inventory -0% inventory trend slope
-36% vs 12-mo avg pct vs trailing 12mo
sale prices -1.2%/mo median sale trend slope
86 days on market median days on market
26% of listings cutting price price drop frequency
2% relisted listing reappearance rate

Current Inventory Snapshot

Active priced listings2761
Median fair value$6,818
Avg deal score56/100

Comparable Markets

MarketUndervaluationAppreciationLiquidity
BMW 1M Coupe (E82) 515262
Nissan 350Z 525455
Nissan 350Z NISMO 531257
Nissan 370Z 494448
Alfa Romeo 4C 525039
Fiat 500 (2012-2019) 682549
Porsche 718 Boxster/Cayman 484743
Porsche 718 Boxster/Cayman GT4 244938

Recent Signals & Alerts

Data-backed market intelligence, not a guaranteed prediction. Figures are modeled estimates from asking prices, sold comps, and public economic indicators; they can be wrong. Not financial advice.