Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Price Guide & Market Report

Updated November 21, 2026 | 163 active listings | 66 confirmed sales

As of November 21, 2026, a typical Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) is worth about $4,900, with a fair range of $4,300 to $5,500 (CarSearch.Pro True Value). That figure is based on 18 recent confirmed sales and adjusted for mileage. As of November 21, 2026, sellers ask a median of $4,188, while CarSearch.Pro's sale-anchored True Value is $4,900. Asks are about 15% below what these cars sell for.

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009): Quick Answers

Numbers as of November 21, 2026, from listings and confirmed sales tracked by CarSearch.Pro.

What is a fair price for a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009)?

As of November 21, 2026, a typical Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) is worth about $4,900, with a fair range of $4,300 to $5,500 (CarSearch.Pro True Value). That figure is based on 18 recent confirmed sales and adjusted for mileage.

What does a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) actually sell for compared with asking prices?

As of November 21, 2026, sellers ask a median of $4,188, while CarSearch.Pro's sale-anchored True Value is $4,900. Asks are about 15% below what these cars sell for.

Which Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) model years cost more?

Among model years with at least 3 listings, the 2007 asks the most (median $4,988, 41 listings) and the 2008 the least (median $3,990, 66 listings), as of November 21, 2026.

How does mileage affect Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) value?

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings with under 10,000 mi ask a median of $5,000 (6 listings); those with over 150,000 mi ask a median of $3,800 (198 listings), as of November 21, 2026.

How long do Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings sit before selling?

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings for sale on November 21, 2026 have been listed a median of 83 days so far. 27% carry a recent price cut. Cars listed past 60 days are where sellers are most open to offers.

Are Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) prices going up or down?

CarSearch.Pro's 12-month model points up (53% probability); its past calls on this market were right 39% of the time over 18 tests.

Is a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listing a good deal?

Compare the price with the fair range, $4,300 to $5,500 as of November 21, 2026. Below $4,300 is cheap for this market, so check the mileage, title and history for the reason. Above $5,500 should come with low miles, a rare specification or exceptional condition.

Where is a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) cheapest to buy?

Among states with the most listings, CT has the lowest median ask at $3,495 (15 listings), as of November 21, 2026.

Median Price $4,188
Average Price $6,191
Middle 50% of Asks $3,200 - $5,696
Trend N/A

What a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Is Actually Worth

True Value $4,900
Fair Range $4,300 - $5,500
Median Recent Sold $7,600
Verdict UNDERVALUED

As of November 2026, CarSearch.Pro's True Value model estimates a typical Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) is actually worth $4,900 (fair range $4,300 to $5,500). Unlike the median asking price shown above, True Value is anchored to 18 recent confirmed sales, normalized for mileage, and blends auction hammer prices (grossed up for buyer's premium) with real-world asking behavior.

Sellers are currently asking a median of $4,200 — about 14% below what these cars have actually been selling for. Asks sitting below recent sold values can signal softening demand or motivated sellers.

Undervalued vs trend — but volatile.

See the full Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) investment analysis →

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Market Summary

As of November 2026, the Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) market has 163 active listings across 14 marketplaces tracked by CarSearch.Pro. The median asking price is $4,188, with the middle 50% of listings priced between $3,200 and $5,696.

The typical Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) on the market has 150,000 miles. The cars for sale now have been listed an average of 120 days so far.

Current Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Pricing

The middle half of Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings in November 2026 ask between $3,200 and $5,696 (25th to 75th percentile). Asks range from $2,800 to $7,598 across 415 priced, clean-title listings.

Asking Price Distribution (415 Priced Listings)
Percentile Price Meaning
10th$2,800Budget / project cars
25th$3,200Below average price
Median (50th)$4,188Typical market price
75th$5,696Above average / premium
90th$7,598Top tier / low miles / rare spec

The average asking price is $6,191, which is higher than the median, indicating that high-priced outliers (rare specifications, very low mileage, or concours-quality examples) pull the average up.

Price by Mileage

Mileage RangeListingsMedian Price
Under 10,000 mi6$5,000
10,000 - 25,000 mi4$3,400
25,000 - 50,000 mi2$19,995
50,000 - 100,000 mi45$6,995
100,000 - 150,000 mi139$4,900
Over 150,000 mi198$3,800

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Price Trends

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Quarterly Sale Prices (Historical)
QuarterSalesMedian PriceAverage Price
2025-Q13$10,000$9,833
2025-Q23$10,053$10,234
2025-Q32$15,750$14,375
2025-Q48$9,600$9,275
2026-Q18$7,100$7,615
2026-Q22$5,400$4,500
2026-Q32$8,000$7,650
2026-Q41$5,603$5,603

Best Value Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) by Model Year

The 2008 Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) offers the best value with a median price of $3,990 across 66 listings. The most expensive model year is 2007 at a median of $4,988.

Median Price by Model Year
YearListingsMedian PriceMinMax
2005 118 $4,200 $2,500 $567,890
2006 49 $4,195 $2,500 $9,500
2007 41 $4,988 $2,500 $8,900
2008 66 $3,990 $2,500 $15,000
2009 141 $4,190 $2,500 $19,995

How Mileage Affects Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Value

Most price guides assume value falls linearly with mileage. It doesn't. CarSearch.Pro learns the actual price-vs-mileage curve for the Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) from confirmed sales, referenced to a typical example at about 119,700 miles:

Odometer (approx.)Value MultiplierImplied Value
1,118 mi 1.46x $7,173
6,865 mi 1.15x $5,638
10,607 mi 1.14x $5,566
17,000 mi 1.14x $5,568
47,990 mi 1.15x $5,626
72,561 mi 1.02x $4,977
109,289 mi 0.82x $4,011
141,649 mi 0.87x $4,276
300,000 mi 0.60x $2,929

Low-mileage examples carry a real premium in this market: around 1,118 miles, cars trade at roughly 1.46x the reference value. At the other end, 300,000-mile examples trade at about 0.60x. Implied values here are anchored to this market's True Value.

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Price Forecast

HorizonDirectionProbabilityRegimePast Accuracy
6 months ↑ UP 51% volatile 63% over 24 tests
12 months ↑ UP 53% volatile 39% over 18 tests
24 months ↑ UP 54% volatile insufficient history

These are probabilistic direction calls, not price targets. The "Past Accuracy" column is this model's real walk-forward record on the Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) — every month we re-run the forecast as if we only knew what was knowable then, and grade it against what actually happened. We publish the hit rate either way. Full methodology & track record →

Where to Buy a Subaru Legacy (2005-2009)

The highest concentration of Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings is in CO with 45 active listings, followed by WA (44), CA (28), TX (26), NY (25).

Regional pricing varies significantly. The lowest median price is in CT at $3,495, while NC has the highest at $5,696. Buyers willing to travel or arrange transport may find savings of $2,201.

Top States by Inventory
StateListingsMedian Price
CO 45 $4,900
WA 44 $3,999
CA 28 $5,500
TX 26 $4,000
NY 25 $4,000
FL 24 $4,000
NJ 23 $4,000
OH 19 $3,500
MA 19 $3,980
GA 15 $3,995

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Market Velocity

The Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings for sale now have been on the market an average of 120 days so far. This is a slow-moving market. Listings tend to sit for extended periods, giving buyers significant negotiating power. Sellers should be realistic on pricing and patient.

The median is 83 days. The lower median means a smaller number of long-listed cars pull the average up.

Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) Buyer's Guide Summary

Ready to start shopping? Browse all 163 Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings with AI quality scores, or get a free AI appraisal on a specific listing.

Data sourced from 7 marketplaces including eBay Motors, Bring a Trailer, Cars & Bids, AutoTrader, CarGurus, Cars.com, Facebook Marketplace, Classic.com, and Hagerty Marketplace. Updated daily by CarSearch.Pro's automated pipeline. Browse all 163 active Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) listings. Read the latest Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) market analysis.