Ferrari 458

ferrari 2009-2015

245 Listings
$275,000 Avg Price
$5,000 From

Showing 73-96 of 245 listings

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia
$159,998

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia

Orlando, FL

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia RWD
$227,995

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia RWD

Tustin, CA

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
$259,990

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

Redwood City, CA

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe RWD
$209,490

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe RWD

Troutdale, OR

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale
$699,950

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale

Scottsdale, AZ

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia RWD
$259,990

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia RWD

Redwood City, CA

2014 Ferrari 458
$399,995

2014 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2015 Ferrari 458
$349,995

2015 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia - Coupe 2D
$259,999

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia - Coupe 2D

Staten Island, NY

2014 Ferrari 458
$399,995

2014 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2015 Ferrari 458
$349,995

2015 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2014 Ferrari 458
$399,995

2014 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
$189,991

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

Houston, TX

2015 Ferrari 458
$349,995

2015 Ferrari 458

Tampa, FL

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia
$314,995

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia

West Palm Beach, FL

Original-Owner 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider
$325,000
AUCTION

Original-Owner 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider

United States

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale
$1,049,995
AUCTION

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale

Unknown

2015 Ferrari 458 Spider
$399,988
AUCTION

2015 Ferrari 458 Spider

Unknown

2013 Ferrari 458 1,600 Original Miles
$458,980

2013 Ferrari 458 1,600 Original Miles

Carrollton, TX

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale - Aperta
$1,699,998

2015 Ferrari 458 Speciale - Aperta

Fort Lauderdale, FL

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
$209,995

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

Pembroke Pines, FL

2010 Ferrari 458 Base
$236,490

2010 Ferrari 458 Base

Orlando, FL

2010 Ferrari 458 Base
$238,995

2010 Ferrari 458 Base

Orlando, FL

2010 Ferrari 458 Base
$236,490

2010 Ferrari 458 Base

Orlando, FL

Ferrari 458 Market Overview

Built by Ferrari from 2009-2015, the Ferrari 458 is tracked across 245 active listings from 8 marketplaces including eBay Motors, Bring a Trailer, Cars & Bids, AutoTrader, CarGurus, Cars.com, and Facebook Marketplace. Each listing is analyzed by AI for quality, value, and condition.

Ferrari 458 Pricing Data

As of April 2026, the median asking price for a Ferrari 458 is $279,900, with an average of $410,632. The middle 50% of listings (25th to 75th percentile) are priced between $235,995 and $369,999. The median mileage across active listings is 15,800 miles. Listings spend an average of 57 days on market before selling or being removed.

Where to Find a Ferrari 458

The highest concentration of Ferrari 458 listings by state: FL (41), NY (21), CA (19), TX (17), NJ (9). Listings are sourced from Classic.com (72), Cars.com (57), eBay Motors (41), CarGurus (33), Facebook Marketplace (23), AutoTrader Classics (13).

Ferrari 458 by Model Year

The most commonly listed model year is 2015 with 56 listings. Year breakdown: 2015 (56 listings), 2013 (42 listings), 2014 (37 listings), 2012 (36 listings), 2010 (27 listings).

Ferrari 458 Sales History

CarSearch.Pro tracks 500 historical Ferrari 458 sales from auction houses and dealer records. In 2026-Q2, the median sale price was $233,000 across 1 sales, down 24.8% from 2026-Q1 ($309,999).

Ferrari 458 Quarterly Sale Prices
QuarterSalesMedian PriceAverage Price
2025-Q150$254,950$312,578
2025-Q265$238,000$303,136
2025-Q3104$248,491$317,402
2025-Q4100$249,995$380,176
2026-Q162$309,999$548,183
2026-Q21$233,000$233,000